More Pages: Marshall Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100


A Book with a Value

Must-read while studying McLuhan

Foundations of the post-WW2 World OrderThe Marshall Plan, By Charles L. Mee, Jr., Simon & Schuster Inc., 1984. Mee's masterful book uses the Marshall Plan as window into not just the economic and political reconstruction of Europe after World War 2, but also into the ideological and diplomatic creation of a bipolar world called "containment" and Cold War. Along the way, he tells us something of the people who engineered this process, and of the maneuverings they undertook to shape it. European economic recovery and social reconstruction were not spontaneous or pre-determined. Solutions to the economic destruction of Europe had to be found in a political environment of domestic instabilities and international disagreements on questions like the place of Germany, the role of the Americans, and the relationship between Europe East and West. The Americans came to see that the best way to overcome Western European bickering was to unite those count! ries against a common Soviet foe, smoothing over the worst inter-European disagreements by orchestrating economic recovery as a political emergency requiring American leadership. This book is really a study of America's coming of age as the leading political and economic power in the world, made manifest by the insertion of the United States into the heart of European economy and "security." The Cold War was the ideological and diplomatic pavement over which American capital, ideas, and guns were made to dominate the "free" (market) world. Mee sets the scene for this pax Americana with an exposition of Kennan's "Long Telegraph" and "sources of Soviet Conduct" paper. Kennan proved to be a brilliant ideologist for the American ruling class, pointing out real weaknesses in the Stalinist system in a way that dismissed a strawman Marxism while inspiring American feelings of moral superiority and political emergency. Ignoring the Stalinis! ts' liquidation of the original Bolsheviks, Kennan turned t! he international class struggle described by Marx and Lenin into a conflict between American morals and freedom against a neurotic Russian insecurity and fanatical subversion campaign. Mee doesn't critique Kennan as I have, but he rightly places the Marshall Plan into the larger policy of "containment," which really called for "the containment of Russian expansionism, for rebuilding and containing Germany at the same time, for rebuilding and containing France and England, for rebuilding and containing a whole new array of economic relationships in such a way that the United States could exercise influence over them all.... As an extra, but by no means negligible, bonus, the policy would also --by bringing economic and political stability to Europe and saving the governments there from a crisis of confidence or collapse-- keep in power those classes that had traditionally ruled on the Continent and with whom Americans had become accustomed to doing business.&quo! t; (p.92) The Marshall Plan itself was cleverly presented as a generous aid plan open to the Russians and East Europeans as much as to the West, but constructed to ensure their refusal of participation. Mee quotes Kennan on one of the prices of Soviet participation, which "would have been cooperation in overcoming real barriers in East-West trade," which Mee then says "would have meant subjecting themselves to the influence of a more powerful, American economy." (p. 136) Eastern Europe was essential to Russian recovery, argues Mee, because the United States had blocked the two preferable Russian options: an American loan or reparations from Germany --"so the third Russian alternative came into play --the industrial output of Eastern Europe. Czechoslovak and Polish output is being integrated into with the Soviet economy." (p. 137, Mee is quoting from Spectator magazine.) The execution of the plan itself is given only one chapter. The most! important and immediate effects were psychological, combin! ing a feeling of hope with an insinuation of the saving powers of friendship with America. Europe was overrun by American capital and experts, who came to displace European leftists in the battle for Europe's future. The Marshall Plan was "swallowed up" (Kennan's words) by the Korean War, which meant that "soon, 80 percent of American aid to Europe went for defense." (p. 260) But by then the Marshall Plan had a new sister, the NATO alliance created in April 1949. The postwar world had crystallized into an American world: "And where the Truman Doctrine had failed, the Marshall Plan and NATO succeeded: America broke out of its historic, self-imposed isolation in the Western Hemisphere and engaged the rest of the world --economically, politically, and militarily-- as a global power." (p.261) --Reviewed by Will Wilkin


informative, clearly written

A nice illustration of the interpretation power of economicsSutton's book is a very nice piece of work that would help resolve tthis puzzle. Start with the STANDARD PARADIGM commonly used in modeling complex issues in social sciences, particularly in economics, Sutton pins down the limitations of these paradigm in a very easy understanding yet profound way. The next chapter starts some models that work, from a game theoretical perspective. Chapter 3, however, emphasizes the difficulties of constructing a complete model. Finally, the last chapter provides a vivid example of Sutton's argument regarding the pitfalls of modeling and its application in real life.
This nice little book is by far the best I have read in terms of explaining why social sciences are so messy, even with the introduction of nice, elegant mathematical models. It is hard to find "black-and-write" answers in social science, indeed. However, bearing in mind the importance and limitation of using mathematical models would help social scientists face the and frustration in a constructive way.


the human side of large egos making enormous decisions

Mary Alice Returns by Will HermanI would recommend this to people because it shows how much people care for little things like someone saying help. Mary Alice was a very good duck and more people should be like her. This would be a very good book for little kids that like to read funny stories.


This is one of my all-time favorites!The story and the pictures are wonderfully funny. I especially love the picture of Mary Alice wearing her pink bunny slippers.
What makes this story even better is that it lends itself to dramatic storytelling. I use different voices for the various characters in the story.
My kids and I thoroughly enjoy Mary Alice Operator Number 9 and I know you will, too.


As relevant today as it was fifty years ago

Marshall knew it back then what is right here, right now!